ADVERTISING DISCLOSURE: is an independent, advertising-supported web site. receives compensation from most credit card issuers whose offers appear on our site. Compensation from our advertising partners impacts how and where their products appear on our site, including, for example, the order in which they may appear within review lists. has not reviewed all available credit card offers in the marketplace.

Credit Card Applications » News » Other » US Court of Appeals Upholds Trial Court Decision In Favour Of VISA

US Court of Appeals Upholds Trial Court Decision In Favour Of VISA

February 24, 2010 | Updated on February 24, 2010
Add to Favorites:
The content is accurate at the time of publication and is subject to change.

A US Courts of Appeal judge affirmed the earlier ruling of a US trial court that visa card acted appropriately when it reversed the fund transfer it had made to a merchant affiliate. It also junked appeals of the said merchant, ANS, saying that the contract they and VISA signed stipulated that Visa can reclaim any fund transfer on behalf of the company if it finds any fraudulent activity in a given transaction.

ANS, a company that engages in selling and distribution of gas supplies and equipment, forged a partnership with VISA, making the credit issuer a payment partner. Under their contract, clients of ANS can use visa cards to pay for products and services that they purchase. VISA then transfers funds representing the purchases to ANS accounts. It was also stated in this contract that VISA has the right to take back funds that they have transferred to ANS if they find a particular transaction, upon which a card was used, to be fraudulent.

This case stemmed from an incident in 2005, wherein VISA transferred funds to ANS from VISA credit card purchases made by the gas supply dealer's clients in Singapore. Amount of the purchase totalled to $150,000. However, upon inspection the credit card company discovered that this transaction was fraudulent and promptly took funds back from ANS.

ANS countered by filing a court case against VISA stating that the latter acted illegally when it took money back from the former and that Visa failed to acknowledge a verbal agreement it had with ANS about fraud investigation.

When this case was first heard in a trial court, the presiding judge ruled in favour of the defendant stating that VISA was within bounds when it decided to recover the money from ANS. He stated that VISA's actions were prescribed in a mutual contract between the two companies. ANS filed a motion for appeal and requested that the verdict be reviewed.

During the hearings in the Appellate court, ANS presented a witness its comptroller, Thomas Spencer, who under oath stated that VISA charged higher transaction fees for purchases made online, which his company believed is for the additional fraudulent investigation services that the credit issuer would perform for transactions done online.

However, Spencer failed to produce evidence such as contracts or memorandum or agreements that would prove that VISA indeed would be charging for fraudulent check activities made for online purchases.

A lack of supporting evidence left the Court of Appeals no choice, but to reaffirm the earlier decision of the concerned US trial court, acquitting VISA of all charges made by ANS.

Disclaimer: This editorial content is not provided or commissioned by the credit card issuer(s). Opinions expressed here are the author's alone, not those of the credit card issuer(s), and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the credit card issuer(s). Reasonable efforts are made to present accurate information, however all information is presented without warranty. Consult a card's issuing bank for the terms & conditions.
All rates and fees, and other terms and conditions of the products mentioned in this article/post are actual as of the last update date but are subject to change. See the current products' Terms & Conditions on the issuing banks' websites.
Add to Favorites:
Get the latest news, articles and expert advice delivered to your inbox. It's FREE.
You've successfully subscribed!

Please specify the following:All these fields are optional

Your Credit History
Themes you are interested in:

By providing this information you help us make our news letters more useful and informative. Thank you!